Notes
Outline
Outside Professional Activities
What You Should Know
Research Education Series
January 29, 2003
What Is Conflict of Interest?
What Is Conflict of Interest?
Not based on outcome, but on situation
No distinction between “actual” and “potential”
Not misconduct, per se
BACKGROUND
Current USC Policy evolved over a five year period in response to Federal regulatory policy (1990-95)
Public Health Service (PHS) – Objectivity in Research
National Science Foundation (NSF) – Financial Disclosure Policy
Final Rule Issued – July 11, 1995
Federal Policy Mandates
Maintain an appropriate written and enforced policy on conflict of interest (complies with federal requirements and inform investigators of the policy)
Designate an institutional official(s) to solicit and review financial disclosure statements from each investigator planning to participate in research
Require that investigators submit disclosure of financial interests prior to submission of application for funding
Federal Policy - Disclosure
Required for all NSF and PHS funding applications
Applies to those involved with the design, conduct, or reporting of research
Related financial interests must be disclosed
Federal Policy - Disclosure
“Financial Interest”
Income > $10,000 (salary, fees, honoraria, dividends)
Equity > $10,000 or a 5% ownership interest
Intellectual property interest on a patent, patent application, or copyright of software assigned to a party other than USC
Federal Policy - Disclosure
“Financial Interest” related to a sponsored project
Will manufacture or commercialize a product that will predictably result from the project
Results would be relevant to the development, manufacture, or improvement of a product
Income from consulting > $10,000
Result in subcontract, lease of property or procurement
Referral of participants or collaborations
USC Policy – ACAF 1.50
Provides overall framework for unit policies
Each unit having separate tenure and promotion criteria  required to have a policy
Review of unit policies by the USC Conflict of  Interest Committee
Last of 43 unit policies approved (July 1995)
ACAF 1.50 - Requirements
Faculty will seek prior administrative approval of outside professional activities, and will report these activities annually
ACAF 1.50 - Definitions
Faculty – all administrators holding academic appointments and all professors, associate professors, assistant professors, full-time academic instructors and full-time lecturers who are not degree candidates
Financial Interest – any monetary interest which could be construed as having a potential impact on University-related work
Immediate Family – an individuals spouse, children, parents, and/or other members of the individuals household
What Should Be Reported
Compensated services
Contract with any private sector entity
Ownership or equity in a business or corporation
Management or board position in a business or corporation
Participation in a contract or proposal through an entity other than the University
What Should Be Reported
Participation in service or teaching contract with another college or university
Academic remuneration noted as fees or honoraria
Unpaid consulting or pro bono service
What Should Be Reported
Activities not normally reported
Colloquia
Textbooks
Paintings
Performances
Faculty Reports - Content
Type of activity
Whether the activity is compensated
Duration/time requirements
Explanation of any potential conflict of interest or commitment
Whether the activity involves the use of University facilities, resources, personnel (including students) or other commitment and whether appropriate procedures have been followed
Reporting Procedure
Supervisor Responsibilities
Determination of conflict of interests or financial conflict
Recommendations to prevent or reduce conflicts to a manageable level
Required public disclosure
Monitoring by independent reviewers
Modification of research plan
Disqualification from participation in research
Divestiture of significant financial interests
Severance of relationships that create conflicts